Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has rejected United States President Donald Trump’s 15-point plan for Gaza, saying that Israeli forces is not going to withdraw till Hamas is “genuinely disarmed”.
“Israel rejects the 15-point doc,” he stated at a cupboard assembly, stressing that Hamas should surrender all of its weapons earlier than any pull-back.
Really useful Tales
listing of 4 gadgetsfinish of listing
Trump late final month introduced a breakthrough within the US-led ceasefire framework, saying that Hamas and different armed teams in Gaza had accepted a phased plan underneath which they might give up their weapons to a brand new Palestinian governing physique, and Israel would start pulling out troops in tandem with disarmament.
Netanyahu, underneath stress from his right-wing base forward of elections, has seemingly hardened his stance after days of mounting criticism of the plan.
So, what’s Trump’s 15-point plan, and why has Israel rejected it?
What’s Trump’s 15-point plan?
On July 30, the US-led Board of Peace proposed a 15-point roadmap for Gaza, detailing a phased, conditional framework for disarmament and reconstruction within the war-torn coastal enclave.
The plan mandates that Hamas disarm in change for a full Israeli navy withdrawal and the transition of governance to an impartial Palestinian Nationwide Committee, supported by a global safety drive.
The Board of Peace, created by Trump in October with him serving as its lifetime chair, is led by the US authorities. United Nations Safety Council (UNSC) Decision 2803 designates it the physique accountable for overseeing the Gaza peace plan.
Trump stated the settlement can be carried out in levels, with Israeli forces withdrawing because the disarmament course of advances.
Regardless of the framework, important challenges stay, as Hamas hinges its compliance on an finish to Israel’s genocidal actions.
A member of Hamas’s negotiating delegation final month informed Al Jazeera that the group’s implementation of the settlement might be depending on Israel fulfilling its commitments.
Nonetheless, the Board of Peace earlier this week stated an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza will solely happen after the disarmament of Hamas is full.
Israel has killed greater than 73,300 Palestinians in Gaza since its genocidal struggle started in October 2023. And since agreeing to a US-mediated “ceasefire” with Hamas in October 2025, it has continued to hold out strikes on Gaza, killing greater than 1,200 Palestinians, in line with the Gaza Well being Ministry.
What did Netanyahu say whereas rejecting the deal?
The Israeli military “is not going to perform any withdrawal till Hamas is genuinely disarmed and can proceed to thwart threats in opposition to our forces and our residents”, the Israeli prime minister stated.
Netanyahu added that Israel was participating with Washington over its issues concerning the plan.
“They’ve concepts; a few of them are acceptable to us, and a few should not, and we all know methods to stand our floor on these issues,” he stated.
The Israeli chief, who is anticipated to face a tricky nationwide election in October this 12 months, with successive surveys exhibiting he’s heading in the right direction to lose, stated that Hamas should surrender all of its weapons.
“We’re speaking about actual disarmament, not fictitious disarmament,” Netanyahu stated.
Al Jazeera’s Nour Odeh, reporting from the occupied West Financial institution, stated discussions across the 15-point plan, together with Hamas’s disarmament and Israel’s potential withdrawal, “are extraordinarily controversial for the [Netanyahu-led] right-wing authorities”.
“Evidently Netanyahu, so near elections, has hit the reset button, saying that none of that may occur underneath his watch,” she stated.
“That is extraordinarily problematic for the Board of Peace and the mediators who’ve been working for months now to attempt to discover a approach to perform the disarmament of Hamas and have Israel decide to a phased withdrawal from Gaza.”
How have Palestinians reacted?
Al Jazeera’s Hani Mahmoud, reporting from Gaza Metropolis, stated most individuals within the war-battered coastal enclave “anticipated” Israel to reject the proposal.
“The one concern that folks have proper now’s that that is translating into better uncertainty,” he reported, including that the plan “was meant to supply extra construction and a framework”.
“There are necessary components that had been a part of the plan when it comes to safety: Israeli withdrawal from the realm that it has been occupying over the previous years throughout Gaza often called the ‘Yellow Line’, the disarmament of Hamas, in addition to the entry of worldwide stabilisation forces. Now, the total rejection right here places the sequencing and the steps to finish that into critical query. It interprets into no clear finish to hostilities and wars.”
Political analyst and former adviser to the Palestinian negotiations workforce Xavier Abu Eid says the Board of Peace and UNSC Decision 2803 had been accepted late final 12 months as a result of it was argued at the moment that they had been the one approach to finish the Israeli genocide in Gaza.
“But it surely was very clear from the very starting that the 20-point plan of President Trump and the 15-point disarmament and implementation plan that adopted had been extra about assembly Israeli pursuits than the Palestinian proper to self-determination,” he informed Al Jazeera.
“Justice for Palestinians is one thing that no one talks about. So, definitely, this stays a place,” he stated, including that Trump is unlikely to be pleased with Netanyahu’s rejection.
“However on the identical time, Trump has by no means even pretended to push any kind of accountability measures for Netanyahu violating even their very own agreements,” the analyst stated.
What do the specialists say?
Israeli analyst Dan Perry stated Netanyahu’s transfer in opposition to the proposed Gaza plan is “misaligned with what the individuals in Israel would typically need, in the event that they understood accurately what’s occurring”.
“I’ve no naivety about Hamas. However even when there’s an concept that there’s a declarative settlement to disarm, it’s one thing that needs to be welcomed so clearly,” Perry, the previous chief of The Related Press information company in Europe, Africa and the Center East, informed Al Jazeera.
“I hold listening to a few trade-off between Israeli safety calls for and the apparent wants of the Palestinian individuals, the necessity to alleviate and repair the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, however these should not at loggerheads.”
A lot of Israeli society has backed the genocidal struggle on Gaza following the October 7 assault on southern Israel, in addition to the struggle on Lebanon and Iran.
Alon Pinkas, a former Israeli diplomat, says Netanyahu wants “a perpetually struggle”.
“This Israeli rejection of the Gaza plan … needs to be seen totally within the context of the upcoming Israeli election on October 27,” he informed Al Jazeera.
Pinkas stated Netanyahu made a “calculation that that is threat free”, “that he can supposedly defy Trump as a result of Trump doesn’t care sufficient, due to the sequence, as a result of Hamas hasn’t disarmed but, as a result of he can get away with it”.
“And that is all concerning the perpetually struggle and the election,” he concluded.
