NEW DELHI: Former union minister P Chidambaram has opposed the proposed ‘One Nation, One Election’ framework earlier than a joint parliamentary committee, calling the initiative “unconstitutional”, “monstrous” and “senseless”.Chidambaram, who appeared earlier than the panel inspecting the Structure (129th Modification) Invoice, 2024, and the Union Territories Legal guidelines (Modification) Invoice, 2024, argued that synchronising Lok Sabha and state meeting elections might violate the constitutional framework governing elected legislatures.Sources, quoted by information company PTI, mentioned the previous residence and finance minister instructed the panel that since legislatures are elected for five-year phrases, curbing their tenure would quantity to a violation of the fundamental construction of the Structure.Chidambaram additionally mentioned his conscience didn’t enable him to assist the proposed laws and argued that the federal government doesn’t have the required two-thirds majority to go the payments, sources instructed PTI.The Congress chief described the proposal to carry nationwide elections concurrently as a “senseless” train and strongly opposed the federal government’s push for simultaneous polls.Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Sagarika Ghosh, who can be a member of the committee, individually opposed the payments. Ghosh mentioned the proposal might give “unbridled” energy to the Election Fee, sources mentioned.The joint committee, headed by BJP MP PP Chaudhary, additionally heard representations from round 10 Padma awardees, together with Tarlochan Singh, Navin Khanna, Meenakshi Jain and Niru Kumar. Whereas some supported simultaneous elections, others opposed the proposal, warning that it might result in “chaos” within the nation.
Share your ideas within the feedback
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
The 2 payments had been launched within the Lok Sabha in December 2024 and subsequently referred to the joint committee for detailed examination.The proposal adopted suggestions from a high-level committee headed by former president Ram Nath Kovind, which prompt holding Lok Sabha, state meeting and native physique elections concurrently in a phased method. Union Residence Minister Amit Shah was additionally a member of the panel.India had earlier held Lok Sabha and state meeting elections collectively from 1951-52 by way of 1967. The cycle was disrupted after untimely dissolutions of some state assemblies in 1968 and 1969, adopted by the early dissolution of the Fourth Lok Sabha in 1970 and recent basic elections in 1971.Since then, staggered election cycles have grow to be the norm, with a number of Lok Sabha and state meeting phrases ending earlier than their full five-year tenure.
How do you view the arguments from P Chidambaram concerning this proposal?
3k+ customers shared opinion in the present day
5k+ customers already voted in the present day
3k+ customers shared opinion in the present day
