4 min learnChandigarhAug 26, 2026 04:40 PM IST
The Delhi Excessive Courtroom Tuesday rejected the plea of a Mixed Defence Providers (CDS) candidate looking for admission to the Indian Navy Academy (IMA), holding that he had did not disclose his earlier medical withdrawal from the Nationwide Defence Academy (NDA).
The candidate had certified the CDS-II 2025 examination and sought permission to hitch the IMA-161 course.
A Division Bench of Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Amit Sharma delivered the judgment in Tarun Kumar Tripathi vs Union of India and Ors case.
‘Suppression of a fabric truth’
The courtroom famous that the Could 28, 2025, CDS notification didn’t record prior medical unfitness as a separate floor for disqualification, not like disciplinary withdrawal or lack of officer-like qualities.
Nonetheless, it held that candidates should totally and in truth disclose their medical historical past in order that the armed forces can assess whether or not any earlier incapacity or harm continues to have an effect on their health.
The courtroom discovered the non-disclosure to be materials and deliberate. It mentioned the petitioner knew of his 2022 harm, hospitalisation, and medical situation when he crammed out the shape.
It mentioned his subsequent medical health certificates for the Coast Guard didn’t erase his earlier medical historical past or excuse his failure to reveal it throughout the CDS choice course of. By withholding that info, the courtroom mentioned he prevented the medical boards from assessing whether or not the femoral harm continued to have an effect on his health for Military service.
Story continues under this advert
“Within the prompt case, we discover that the petitioner has given an incorrect declaration about not sustaining any harm or fracture previous to filling out the applying kind. The applying kind was signed on February 23, 2023, and within the declaration given later, he has licensed that he had sustained an harm within the yr 2016,” the courtroom mentioned.
“The topic harm, which has develop into a floor for disqualification, was sustained a lot previous to filling up of the applying kind; clearly, there may be suppression of a fabric truth by the petitioner with regard to an harm sustained earlier”.
From NDA to CDS examination
The petitioner joined the NDA’s 145th course as an Indian Military cadet in April 2021 after being declared medically match. Throughout his fourth-term cross-country run, he suffered a stress fracture in his left femur. A medical board subsequently really helpful his withdrawal on medical grounds, which was permitted in 2022 and at last accepted in February 2024.
His attraction in opposition to this was rejected on February 13, 2024. The board declared him completely unfit for future army service however match for civil employment. He declined surgical procedure that the medical board mentioned may have decreased his incapacity by round 50 per cent. He was not granted a incapacity pension or ex-servicemen advantages.
Story continues under this advert
He later certified for the Coast Guard’s Assistant Commandant examination and was declared medically match by Military Hospital (Analysis and Referral), New Delhi. He additionally certified CDS-II 2025 and secured Benefit Rank 111.
Within the CDS medical examination report dated February 13, 2026, he answered “No” when requested whether or not he had been discharged from any department of the Armed Forces on medical grounds or had been hospitalised for any sickness, operation or harm.
He didn’t obtain becoming a member of directions for IMA. The Military later mentioned he had did not disclose his earlier medical withdrawal from the NDA.
He disclosed that he had beforehand attended the Nationwide Defence Academy, however didn’t point out that he had been medically withdrawn from the NDA following a fracture.
